Jewellery, what to do??

Can I ask who is a top jeweller? And what would you need to make a crit on one of those dawn rose bracelets??

Also in everyones opinion, what is best? The crafted jewellery or jewellery from drops and quest rewards (obviously the latter can give set bonuses as well) ?????? Or does a combination of both suit nicely?

Questions, questions, questions

I'm running a supreme master jeweller.
For critical dawn rose jewellery you need these journals made by scholars, wich needed mithril flakes as well last time i checked,
just to get a decent crit chance.
The critted jewellery is also the guild jewellery, so i have one 100% crit per week (not that great).
At the moment i got 3 or 4 large supreme tokens, but obviously can only make one bracer/ring/etc. since the recipe is one week
cooldown as well.
On bracer i have a 1 day cd still after i made one for Paul, not sure if he wants a 2nd bracer also.

The crafted jewellery is definatly on top of what you can have, there are some good but no better quest rewards.
A couple drops/barter jewellery in the game are better than the crafted for some classes, i think not by much though.

Can I book in for a bracelet please mate, I'll try and get hold of a journal for you. Is it you who needs the mithril flake or the scholar by the way?

Really bracer ? Would think Ring & Earring are much more useful to you ?

You need a flake for the jewellery AND a flake for the journal to get me to about 70% for a crit on normal recipe.
I'm missing some % there cause my jeweller is only level 38.
I tried the journal out of curiosity twice, failed on both crit attempts and never touched that again.